Summary written by Tianna DuPont, WSU Extension Specialist. Rootstock information from Tom Auvil.

Growers often ask which is the ‘best’ apple rootstock. The replant tolerant Geneva rootstocks (G.11, G.41, G.214, G.935, G.210, G.969, G.890) are much better than the available standards of Bud 9, Mark, M.9 clones, M.26 and the semi-dwarf rootstocks. But, which rootstock you use depends on your site, goals and scion. Years of experience will show us which scions will do better on which rootstocks in a given site. Try multiple rootstocks in your site to see which combination is better in your particular location. Here are some considerations from the Washington State Tree Fruit Research Commission trials and recent tour.

Background

England’s East Malling Research station gathered selections and determined trueness to name. Finding many misnamed collections of plant materials Dr. R. Hatton properly divided the 24 selections found and assigned them a Roman numeral. These numerals were not in order by tree size and thus M.9 is smaller than M.2. Of this group M.9, M.7, M.2, M.8 and M.13 have been commercially important in the US. In succeeding years M.26 and M.27 were developed from controlled crosses. In 1917 the John Innes Institute of Merton England joined with East Malling Research Station with an effort toward developing woolly apple aphid resistant rootstocks. Of these Malling-Merton rootstocks, the MM.106 and M.111 are still widely used. In the 1960’s East Malling and Long Ashton research stations in England worked to remove viruses and the resulting incompatibility problems from rootstocks. The resulting ‘cleaned up’ rootstocks are the EMLA group. Since this time most modern rootstocks have had viruses removed. New rootstocks are being developed the first of which was the Budagovsky series designated Bud or B. The newest rootstocks being developed and released are the Geneva series from Cornell University’s breeding program.

Washington Tree Fruit Research Commission Trial

The Washington Tree Fruit Research Commission (WSTFRC) installed Geneva rootstocks trials in three locations with multiple scions in order to evaluate rootstocks in multiple soil types and growing conditions. Trees are managed by growers to approximate their normal growing practices. Trees are now in their third leaf. This fall, fruit evaluations will be conducted, allowing for observations on fruit yield and quality. This trial is meant to complement the national NC140 rootstock trials.

Brief comments on rootstocks in TFRC trial listed from smallest to largest:

Smallest size

Bud.9 is a newer dwarfing rootstock bred in the Soviet Union from the cross of M.8 x Red Standard (Krasnij Standart). Trees in this series are 15-25% smaller than M.9 depending on the cultivar and site. B.9 appears to be resistant to collar rot and very cold hardy.

Small size

Malling 9 (M.9) is the industry standard for dwarfing rootstocks. Numerous clones of M.9 are available from nurseries including the M.9.337 clone used in this trial. Size/vigor: In trials, M9.337 is considered to be 30% of seedling with the same scion and site. Pest/disease resistance: M.9 337 has low replant resistance, no fire blight resistance, no wooly apple aphid resistance and high crown/root rot resistance.

G.11 has the most history of the Geneva rootstocks. For example, McDougall and Son’s Legacy Orchard has 8th leaf trees on G.11 that are performing better than M9.337. Size/vigor: Geneva 11 is considered an excellent M.9 replacement. It does well in loam and clay-loam soils. In sandy soils, it must be planted closer together in order to fill space. Disease/pest resistance: G.11 is not woolly apple aphid resistant. Replant resistant. Crown and root rot resistant. Moderately resistant to fire blight1. Nursery performance: Stable.  Disadvantages: Less tolerant to growing in sandy soil.

G.935 is the most precocious of the Geneva series in these trials. It is a 1935 cross of Ottawa 3 and Robusta 5. Size/vigor: Semi-dwarf reported to be slightly larger than M.26. Production efficiency rated equal to M.9. Disease/pest resistance: It is not resistant to woolly apple aphid. It has fire blight and crown rot resistance. Nursery performance: Very good.  Disadvantages:  Some new plantings have experienced decline. There is no confirmed evidence of hypersensitivity to viruses. Currently researchers are investigating the cause of the decline. Viruses are under suspicion in the decline of G.935 trees based on some association between declining trees and the presence of viruses. In New York both apple chlorotic leaf spot virus and apple stem pitting virus were present in declining trees on G.935. However, in Washington some declining trees tested have tested positive to one or the other virus and others have not. Apple chlorotic leaf spot virus and apple stem pitting virus are extremely common in Washington and often cause few symptoms. A new luteovirus is also being tested. Remember, association is not causation and until further research is conclusive we cannot say what is causing the decline. Research trials are underway at both Cornell and Washington State University to address the decline. Growers should be extremely cautious with G.935 until this issue is further understood.

G.214 is in the M.9 337 size class with fireblight and wooly apple resistance. Size/vigor: G.214 is similar in size to G.11 and G.41 in the M9.337 size class. In TFREC trials it had reasonable croploads in 2nd and 3rd leaf trees indicating potential for precocity. In all three blocks, trees were above the top wire. It filled canopy and grew well. Disease/pest resistance: Replant and fire blight resistant. Wooly apple aphid resistant. Nursery performance: It is nearing commercial availability. Disadvantages: Availability is low due to prior problems with mislabeling of foundation material shipped to tissue culture companies.

Medium Full Dwarf rootstocks

M.9 Nic 29® is 20-25% larger than M.9 337 (25 to 40% of seedling). Nic 29® is a Malling 9 type rootstock. Size/vigor: It usually exhibits a better root system than M.9 337 or M.9 EMLA. Of the various types of Malling 9, Nic 29® exhibits stronger vigor, yet is still a full dwarf. The rootstock is both precocious and productive, usually fruiting in second or third leaf. Disease/pest resistance: Highly susceptible to fire blight. No wooly apple aphid or replant resistance documented. Disadvantages: Root death from fire blight infections before scion symptoms are present.

G.969 is in the large M.9 group of dwarfing rootstocks in Washington trials.  Size/vigor: It is classified as having growth between M.7 and MM.106 in prior Cornell trials. More recent trials from Terrence Robinson at NYSAES Geneva, have transitioned the G.969 classification to significantly smaller. In TFRC trials it was in the size class of Nic 29. Disease/pest resistance: Fire blight, crown rot, and woolly apple aphid resistance. Nursery performance: Excellent, best of the Geneva family.  Disadvantages: Lack of experience with scions, sites, and growers.

G.935 is the most precocious of the Geneva series in these trials. However, some new plantings have had problems that might be virus sensitivity and it should only be planted with fully virus screened scions until the issue is further understood. It is a 1935 cross of Ottawa 3 and Robusta 5. Size/vigor: Semi-dwarf reported to be slightly larger than M.26. Production efficiency rated equal to M.9. Disease/pest resistance: It is not resistant to woolly apple aphid. It has fire blight and crown rot resistance. Nursery performance: Very good.  Disadvantages: Virus sensitivity was not demonstrated in known virus trials. Should be planted with virus-free scions or scions with several years of good results on G.935.

Largest

G.890 is a larger rootstock. It seems able to scavenge for water and nutrients making it a successful replacement tree rootstock. It is considerably more precocious than Malling stocks of similar vigor. Size/vigor: G.890 and G.210 are the most vigorous of the Genevas. Size is similar to an M.7 but with higher and earlier production. In the TFRC trial, G.890 with fruit was bigger than G.210 without fruit. Resistance: Resistant to fire blight, crown rot, and wooly apple aphid. Nursery performance: Very good.  Disadvantages: It is vigorous.

Tips and Comments

Tips for working with G.41. G.41 has had some problems with trees breaking at the union of the scion and the root. This brittleness is associated with high rigidity. Most of this injury happens in the nursery but at the field day, Auvil explained some ways to prevent injury at planting. First, “Don’t buy big trees.” Bigger trees are more susceptible to breakage. “Buy ½ inch whips if you can.” “ ½” whips have very few problems and can be planted mechanically,” Auvil explained. If you do buy larger caliper trees it is important to handle them gently. Build your trellis before you plant. Clip your trees to the trellis as you go and be gentle as you handle the bundle. “Instruct your crew to lift trees with two hands,” Auvil reminded the group. Damage can occur as they untangle the trees. The NC-140 group has also found that BA applications directly to the graft union increased break strength2. Apogee also increased strength but reduced scion growth.

Freestanding trees? Participants asked which rootstocks could be freestanding trees. Auvil reminded them that free standing is a cultural practice, not a rootstock trait. Any rootstock in the trial would have to be headed back multiple times to create a free standing tree. Rootstocks that have good anchorage can be cultivated into free standing. Pruning, especially to develop free standing trees, will significantly delay fruiting.

Availability. G.11, G.41, and G.935 are widely available, however demand is larger than supply.  Other Genevas are available in smaller quantities and by pre-arranged contractual agreements. At the present time most of all the dwarfing rootstocks have pre-arranged contractual agreements in place. It is best to reserve your rootstock for the future as soon as possible and then determine the variety you want on it prior to budding.

G.41, G.935 and G.11 have the most plant material available of the Geneva’s

Favorite? Scott McDougall and Auvil explained that G.41 is the best all-around rootstock available right now. It has replant, fireblight, and woolly resistance and has performed well across soil types. G.969 looks like it will have a good future as growers gain experience with the very new rootstock and will be a good Nic 29 replacement. G.969 is easier to plant and stands up nicely in the nursery.

1 In Cornell trials G.11 plants inoculated with fire blight developed 25% infection under high inoculation pressure with one of four strains of E. amylovora.

Attributes: Adapted from information provided to the Good Fruit Grower by Tom Auvil and Dr. Gennaro Fazio, Feb 2016.
Attributes: Adapted from information provided to the Good Fruit Grower by Tom Auvil and Dr. Gennaro Fazio, Feb 2016.
Figure 1. Third leaf Pzazz trees in new ground in Brewster WA, August 2017.
Figure 1. Third leaf Pzazz trees in new ground in Brewster WA, August 2017.
Figure 2. Third leaf Honeycrisp trees in a non-fumigated old orchard site in Oroville WA, August 2017.
Figure 2. Third leaf Honeycrisp trees in a non-fumigated old orchard site in Oroville WA, August 2017.
Third leaf Honeycrisp in new ground in East Wenatchee WA, August 2017.
Third leaf Honeycrisp in new ground in East Wenatchee WA, August 2017.

Additional Information

http://treefruit.wsu.edu/varieties-breeding/rootstocks/

http://articles.extension.org/pages/60736/apple-rootstock-characteristics-and-descriptions

NC-140 Regional Research Project http://www.nc140.org

Geneva Rootstock Trial Update 2016 http://treefruit.wsu.edu/news/geneva-rootstock-performance-2016-rootstock-trial-update/

Virus Sensitivity in G 935 http://treefruit.wsu.edu/news/virus-sensitivity-in-g-935/

References

2Adams, S. Black, B.L., Fazio, G., Roberts, N.A. 2017. Journal of the American Pomological Society. 71(1): 8-18 2017

Penn State Tree Fruit Production Guide. 2016.

WTFRC_Logo